Why do time-temperature curves matter in tunnel fire protection?

Time-temperature fire curves are graphical representations that show the relationship between temperature and time during a fire. These curves are crucial for understanding the thermal stress to which tunnel structures and materials are subjected during a fire. By analysing these curves, engineers can design fire protection systems that ensure the structural integrity of the tunnel and the safety of those inside it.

Which time-temperature curves are used for tunnels?

There are several standard time-temperature curves used in tunnel fire protection planning, each representing a different fire scenario. The most commonly used curves are:

1. Standard fire curve (ISO 834)
2. Hydrocarbon (HC) fire curve
3. Rijkswaterstaat (RWS) curve
4. Modified hydrocarbon curve (HCM)
5. ZTV-ING/RABT curve
6. EBA curve (EUREKA)

Let’s examine each of these curves in detail.

Overview of fire curves

1. Standard fire curve (ISO 834)
The standard fire curve, also known as the ISO 834 curve, is the most commonly used fire curve in building design. It is sometimes also used in tunnel fire protection. It represents a typical building fire scenario involving a cellulose fire and is defined by the following equation:
 

T(t) = T₀ + 345 log₁₀(8t + 1) where:
 

- ( T(t) ) is the temperature at time ( t ),
- ( T_0 ) is the initial temperature (usually 20°C),
- ( t ) is the time in minutes.

This curve is characterised by a gradual rise in temperature and reaches approximately 1,000 °C after 120 minutes. Whilst it is useful for general fire safety design, it cannot accurately represent the more severe fire conditions that may occur in tunnels.

2. Hydrocarbon (HC) fire curve
The hydrocarbon fire curve is used to describe fires involving hydrocarbon fuels such as petrol or diesel, which frequently occur in road tunnels. Compared with the standard fire curve, this curve is characterised by a significantly faster rise in temperature and reaches a maximum of around 1,100 °C. The equation for the HC curve is:
 

T(t) = 1080(1 − 0.325e^(−0.167t) − 0.675e^(−2.5t)) + 20


3. Rijkswaterstaat (RWS) curve
The Rijkswaterstaat (RWS) curve is specifically designed for road tunnels and represents a very severe fire scenario. It was developed by the Dutch Ministry of Infrastructure and Water Management (Rijkswaterstaat) and is characterised by an extremely rapid rise in temperature, peaking at 1,350 °C. It is based on a tanker fire with 45,000 litres of petrol; in the modified variant, the 1,200 °C reached after two hours is maintained for a further hour. Unlike the HC and HCM curves, the RWS curve is defined by tabulated time-temperature values rather than a single equation.
 


This curve is particularly useful for planning fire protection systems in tunnels with high traffic volumes and the potential for major vehicle fires.

4. Modified hydrocarbon curve (HCM)
The modified hydrocarbon curve (HCM) was developed in France from the HC curve to reflect the higher safety requirements of tunnels. It reaches a maximum of 1,300 °C (HC curve: 1,100 °C) and is increasingly used in large international infrastructure projects. The HCM curve is defined by:
 

T(t) = 1280(1 − 0.325e^(−0.167t) − 0.675e^(−2.5t)) + 20


This curve provides a more accurate representation of tunnel fires involving hydrocarbons and is used in conjunction with other fire curves to design comprehensive fire protection systems.

Under the CETU guidelines in France, there are more stringent fire safety requirements for road tunnels. Depending on their size and infrastructural importance, the CETU Directive defines four categories: N0, N1, N2 and N3. These categories represent a combination of different time-temperature curves and have the following meanings:

  • N0 = no requirement

  • N1 = HCM 60 minutes and ISO 120 minutes

  • N2 = HCM 120 minutes

  • N3 = HCM 120 minutes and ISO 240 minutes

 

5. ZTV-ING/RABT curve 
The ZTV-ING curve, also known as the RABT curve, is used for road tunnels in Germany. This curve ensures that the load-bearing reinforcement of the tunnel structure does not exceed 300°C. It also requires class A building materials that release no substances harmful to buildings or people in a fire. This curve is crucial for maintaining the structural integrity of tunnels under extreme fire conditions.
 

6. EBA curve (EUREKA) 
The EBA curve is used for railway tunnels and is defined by the German Federal Railway Authority (EBA). This curve simulates the temperature profile of fire gases in railway tunnels and reaches 1,200°C within just 5 minutes. It was confirmed by fire tests on long-distance passenger train cars in the EU project EUREKA (EU 499) and is essential for the design of fire protection systems in railway tunnels.

Aestuver® fire protection boards meet or exceed the requirements of the international time-temperature curves ISO, ZTV-ING, EBA, HC, HCM and RWS.

How are fire curves used in tunnel design?

Time-temperature fire curves are used in various aspects of fire safety design for tunnels, including:

1
Structural fire protection

They help to determine the thermal load on the tunnel structure and to design the necessary protection for concrete and other structural elements.

2
Fire-fighting systems

They assist with the design of fire-extinguishing systems to ensure that they are tailored to the expected temperatures and fire behaviour.

3
Ventilation systems

They provide key information for sizing the ventilation system to effectively control heat and smoke in the event of a fire.

4
Evacuation planning

They help to assess the spread of heat and smoke and to develop tailored evacuation and rescue plans.

1. Structural fire protection


The main application of time-temperature fire curves is in the design of structural fire protection systems. Engineers use these curves to determine the thermal load to which tunnel structures are subjected in the event of a fire. This information is crucial for selecting suitable fire-resistant materials and designing structural elements that can withstand high temperatures without losing their integrity.

For example, concrete linings in tunnels must be designed in such a way that they do not spall (the breaking away of surface layers) at high temperatures. By analysing time-temperature fire curves, engineers can determine the thickness and composition of the concrete linings to ensure that they remain intact in the event of a fire.

This is the same approach taken by our Aestuver® team. To advise clients, engineers and consultants on the selection of suitable tunnel fire protection systems, we review the requirements of the fire curves. Based on this information, we can analyse reports from hundreds of fire tests and recommend the right thickness of Aestuver® tunnel fire protection boards. Aestuver® fire protection boards are regularly and rigorously tested against all the fire curves above.

More on concrete spalling

2. Fire-fighting systems


Time-temperature fire curves also play an important role in the design of fire-fighting systems such as sprinklers and deluge systems. These systems must be capable of controlling or extinguishing fires within the temperature ranges represented by the fire curves. Engineers use the curves to determine the required response times and water flow rates for fire-fighting systems to ensure they are effective in tunnel environments.

3. Ventilation systems

Effective ventilation is crucial for safety in tunnels, as it helps to control smoke and heat. Time-temperature-fire curves help engineers to design ventilation systems that can maintain acceptable conditions for evacuation and firefighting under fire conditions. By understanding the expected temperature rise and the duration of the fire, engineers can determine the capacity and configuration of ventilation systems to ensure they can cope with the thermal and smoke loads during a fire.

More about smoke extraction ducts

4. Evacuation planning


Finally, time-temperature fire curves are used in evacuation planning to ensure the safety of tunnel users. Engineers use these curves to model the spread of heat and smoke during a fire, enabling them to design evacuation routes and procedures that minimise exposure to hazardous conditions. This includes determining the locations of emergency exits, signage and communication systems to guide users to safety.

Find out more about solutions for escape and rescue routes

Conclusion

Time-temperature fire curves are a fundamental tool in fire safety design for tunnels. They provide important information about the thermal loads to which tunnel structures and systems are subjected in the event of a fire, and enable engineers to design effective fire safety measures.

By understanding and applying these curves, engineers can improve the safety and resilience of tunnels and ensure that they can withstand severe fire scenarios, protecting both the structure and its users.

In summary, the use of time-temperature fire curves in fire protection design for tunnels is essential for creating safe and resilient tunnel environments. By utilising these curves, engineers can design fire protection systems that meet the unique challenges posed by tunnel fires and ultimately protect lives and infrastructure.

If you have any specific enquiries regarding fire protection systems designed to meet tunnel fire performance curves, please contact our Aestuver® team.

Get in touch now

Do you have specific requirements?

Our tunnel fire protection specialists will work with you to develop the right solution – from planning support and project-specific fire tests to technical assistance on site.

More Aestuver® products

Aestuver® fire protection boards are used far beyond tunnels – from structural fire protection in buildings to demanding infrastructure projects and specialist applications.

View all products